9
votes
Accepted
What is the threshold to distinguish a birdsong dialect?
I'm pretty confident that the answer is "No" - there is no threshold that can reliably be used to make this decision!
It is common for researchers to argue for the presence of dialect by ...
3
votes
Which Acoustic Indices are useful for low-frequency recordings?
In the noise monitoring world, we regularly look at Third-octave Levels (TOLs) to describe the soundscape, especially in the lower frequencies you are interested in. We use them to help describe ...
2
votes
Which Acoustic Indices are useful for low-frequency recordings?
You might check out the methods used in these papers -
Non-native species change the tune of tundra soils: Novel access to soundscapes of the Arctic earthworm invasion.
Sounding Soil: An Acoustic, ...
2
votes
Which Acoustic Indices are useful for low-frequency recordings?
I suppose you can calculate any acoustic index just on the smaller bin - ie get seewave to calculate for example ACI in the limited range.
Or downsample to 4 or 8 khz and then run your normal scripts ...
2
votes
What is the threshold to distinguish a birdsong dialect?
In earli(er) papers, different dialects were defined if songs of different individuals of one species differed "by more than three element substitutions / deletions / additions" (van Dongen &...
2
votes
Accepted
Is there a minimum duration that maad indices will work on?
I will defer to @DanStowell's reply/comment on whether 1 minute is an OK duration.
Regarding analyzing the last minute, which may be <1 min, I would just exclude this from the data analysis since:
...
1
vote
What is the threshold to distinguish a birdsong dialect?
Just to expand and what Dan said about acoustic spaces: if we project songs from several populations into a low dimensional space (let's say 2 dimensions) representing variation in acoustic structure ...
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible
Related Tags
acoustic-indices × 5soundscape × 2
python × 2
terrestrial × 1
r × 1
analysis × 1
birdsong × 1
anthropogenic-noise × 1
noise-impact × 1